Skip to main content

Haaland’s Controversial Goal Seals Controversial 1-0 Triumph for 10-Man City in Eventful Manchester Derby

Players and referee waiting VAR to confirm whether Haaland's goal should stand

Key Takeaways:

  • Manchester City defeated Manchester United 1-0 in the 199th competitive Manchester Derby last night, despite being reduced to 10 men in the first half
  • Phil Foden became the first City player since 2006 to be sent off in a derby, receiving a red card for a two-footed kick on Bruno Fernandes
  • Erling Haaland scored the only goal after a VAR review, maintaining City’s unbeaten away run at eight matches and moving them to a joint share of the Premier League summit

Match Overview

Manchester City secured a narrow 1-0 win over Manchester United in a Manchester Derby marked by drama and controversy at every turn. The highly anticipated 199th meeting between the local rivals saw City finish the match with ten men following Phil Foden’s dismissal in the first half, but the visitors managed to hold their nerve and claim all three points.

Key Moments and Red Card Controversy

The fixture’s opening phase proved surprisingly subdued, defying the usual high-octane expectations. However, the match sprang to life midway through the first half with an incident involving Bruno Fernandes and Phil Foden. After Fernandes appeared to initially kick Foden during a tussle on the ground, Foden reacted with a two-footed kick to Fernandes’ stomach. As a result, the City midfielder was shown a straight red card, making him the first City player since 2006 to be sent off in a derby against United.

City manager Enzo Maresca had encouraged his team to “embrace the chaos,” and they were certainly tested following Foden’s early exit. Despite their numerical disadvantage, City’s defence remained resilient for the remainder of the half.

United’s Missed Opportunities

Manchester United struggled to capitalise on their extra man before the interval but nearly snatched the lead on the stroke of half-time. Marcus Rashford’s powerful 25-yard free-kick struck the post with City goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma well beaten. The visitors’ woodwork helped again just minutes into the second half when Kobbie Mainoo’s long-range effort also cannoned back off the upright, Donnarumma once more unable to intervene.

Haaland’s Winner and Late Drama

Although United controlled possession and territory, it was City who broke the deadlock. Erling Haaland converted a cross from Josko Gvardiol, with VAR intervening to confirm that Haaland was onside despite Enzo Fernandez’s failed attempt to play the ball from an offside position. The goal, initially ruled out, was awarded after review, heightening the match’s sense of controversy.

Haaland, City’s £125m signing, nearly extended the advantage moments later, forcing Senne Lammens into a superb save as Haaland’s curled attempt was tipped onto the post. United’s response consisted of a Bryan Mbeumo header and a distant drive from Fernandes, but they failed to trouble Donnarumma consistently after going behind.


100% up to $1000 Sign up Bonus
18+ New customers only. 100% match bonus up to $1000. Min deposit $50. 10x rollover requirement. Promocode: MYB100
»