Key Takeaways:
- Everton defeated Manchester United 1:0 at Old Trafford, with Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall scoring the only goal in the 29th minute
- Everton played with ten men from the 13th minute, after Idrissa Gueye was sent off for a striking incident involving his own teammate
- This result marked Manchester United’s fourth defeat of the Premier League season and ended their five-match unbeaten league run
Match Analysis
Everton overcame the odds to claim all three points at Old Trafford, defeating Manchester United 1:0 in the final fixture of the Premier League’s twelfth round. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall’s spectacular strike in the 29th minute proved decisive for the visitors, who had been reduced to ten men after Idrissa Gueye’s highly unusual dismissal in the 13th minute. Gueye received a red card following a heated exchange in which he struck fellow Everton defender Michael Keane, prompting referee Tony Harrington to intervene and send off the Senegalese midfielder.
🚨🚨| 𝐑𝐄𝐂𝐎𝐑𝐃: Everton become the ONLY team in history to beat Manchester United at Old Trafford with 10-men. 🤯👏 pic.twitter.com/3ouckZgQlo
— CentreGoals. (@centregoals) November 24, 2025
The loss is Manchester United’s fourth of the campaign and their second at home, with a prior defeat to Arsenal at the beginning of the season. Everton’s victory not only brought them level on points with their hosts but also ended United’s sequence of five consecutive undefeated league matches.
First-Half Events
The opening period was marked by physicality and inaccuracy from both sides. The first significant opportunity fell to Everton in the 7th minute, as Iliman Ndiaye delivered a cross from the right that was narrowly intercepted by United’s Leny Yoro before a blue-shirted attacker could connect. Manchester United forwards, particularly Joshua Zirkzee, struggled with composure, offering Everton chances to capitalise on mistakes and break forward.
Everton were forced into an early substitution on 10 minutes, with David Moyes introducing a replacement for the injured Seamus Coleman. United’s first genuine attacking threat emerged in the 12th minute when Bryan Mbeumo drifted into the box, but hesitation allowed Everton to recover. Bruno Fernandes followed up with a strong effort, only to be denied by Jordan Pickford.
Soon after, tempers flared amongst the visitors, culminating in Gueye’s infamous red card for striking Keane. Down to ten players, Everton retreated into a compact defensive shape, relying on physical play to disrupt United’s rhythm. Despite their numerical disadvantage, Everton found a spell of possession past the halfway point, ultimately leading to Dewsbury-Hall’s decisive goal – a superb finish from the edge of the penalty area under the crossbar.
Second-Half Performance
At the interval, Rúben Amorim shuffled his line-up, bringing Mason Mount on for Noussair Mazraoui and redeploying Amad Diallo at right wing-back. United’s attacking play lacked coherence, with frequent misplaced passes and speculative crosses easily handled by Everton’s organised defence. Kobbie Mainoo and Diogo Dalot entered the fray ten minutes into the half to inject fresh impetus, but breakthroughs remained elusive.
Manchester United’s most promising moments came late on. In the 70th minute, Mason Mount set up Bruno Fernandes inside the penalty area, only for the captain to shoot wide from close range. A succession of dangerous deliveries from Luke Shaw and others were consistently met by Jordan Pickford, whose saves from Zirkzee’s headers in the 79th and 89th minutes preserved Everton’s advantage. Despite a late surge, United failed to breach the visitors’ defence and left the pitch without reward.
Conclusion
Everton’s resilient display, highlighted by Dewsbury-Hall’s first-half strike and Jordan Pickford’s commanding performance in goal, saw the visitors claim a valuable away victory. Manchester United, meanwhile, continue to struggle for consistency, raising further questions after another frustrating performance at Old Trafford.
